2013_David Ortiz, Boston (LA)
2012_Pablo Sandoval, San Francisco (LN)
2011_David Freese, San Luis (LN)
2010_Edgar Rentería, San Francisco (LN)
2009_Hideki Matsui, Nueva York (LA)
2008_Cole Hamels, Filadelfia (LN)
2007_Mike Lowell, Boston (LA)
2006_David Eckstein, San Luis (LN)
2005_Jermaine Dye, Chicago (LA)
2004_Manny Ramírez, Boston (LA)
2003_Josh Beckett, Florida (LN)
2002_Troy Glaus, Anaheim (LA)
2001_Curt Schilling y Randy Johnson, Arizona (LN)
2000_Derek Jeter, Nueva York (LA)
1999_Mariano Rivera, Nueva York (LA)
1998_Scott Brosius, Nueva York (LA)
1997_Livan Hernández, Florida (LN)
1996_John Wetteland, Nueva York (LA)
1995_Tom Glavine, Atlanta (LN)
1994_No se disputó
1993_Paul Molitor, Toronto (LA)
1992_Pat Borders, Toronto (LA)
1991_Jack Morris, Minnesota (LA)
1990_José Rijo, Cincinnati (LN)
1989_Dave Stewart, Oakland (LA)
1988_Orel Hershiser, Los Angeles (LN)
1987_Frank Viola, Minnesota (LA)
1986_Ray Knight, Nueva York (LN)
1985_Bret Saberhagen, Kansas City (LA)
1984_Alan Trammell, Detroit (LA)
1983_Rick Dempsey, Baltimore (LA)
1982_Darrell Porter, San Luis (LN)
1981_Ron Cey, Pedro Guerrero y Steve Yeager, Los Angeles (LN)
1980_Mike Schmidt, Filadelfia (LN)
1979_Willie Stargell, Pittsburgh (LN)
1978_Bucky Dent, Nueva York (LA)
1977_Reggie Jackson, Nueva York (LA)
1976_Johnny Bench, Cincinnati (LN)
1975_Pete Rose, Cincinnati (LN)
1974_Rollie Fingers, Oakland (LA)
1973_Reggie Jackson, Oakland (LA)
1972_Gene Tenace, Oakland (LA)
1971_Roberto Clemente, Pittsburgh (LN)
1970_Brooks Robinson, Baltimore (LA)
1969_Donn Clendenon, Nueva York (LN)
1968_Mickey Lolich, Detroit (LA)
1967_Bob Gibson, San Luis (LN)
1966_Frank Robinson, Baltimore (LA)
1965_Sandy Koufax, Los Angeles (LN)
1964_Bob Gibson, San Luis (LN)
1963_Sandy Koufax, Los Angeles (LN)
1962_Ralph Terry, Nueva York (LA)
1961_Whitey Ford, Nueva York (LA)
1960_Bobby Richardson, Nueva York (LA)
1959_Larry Sherry, Los Angeles (LN)
1958_Bob Turley, Nueva York (LA)
1957_Lew Burdette, Milwaukee (LN)
1956_Don Larsen, Nueva York (LA)
1955_Johnny Podres, Brooklyn (LN)
